Undefeated Analysis.
Undefeated is
an observational documentary about the struggles of a high school football team
called the Manassas Tigers of Memphis, as they attempt to win a season after
years of losses, with the help of coach Bill Courtney, it was released in 2011 and directed by Daniel Lindsay,
and T.J. Martin and the production studio The Weinstein Company signed a seven
figure deal to distribute the documentary. It has on an Oscar to ‘Best
Documentary’. I believe the message of the film is that character is going to
be revealed. So I believe the filmmaker chose this story to convey this message
because in the film there are so many different personalities that it then
makes the film interesting.
The features
of an observational documentary are they simply and naturally observe lived
life with minimum intervention. This mode often eschews voice-over commentary,
meaning they have no narration. It also has non-diegetic music which co-insides with the
mood of the people in the film. For example, during their second game, they
were losing so a sombre soft tune plays until the second half when the
first touchdown happens, it alters to an upbeat tune, almost sounding like
victorious. I think the filmmaker used these because it adds to the effect of
the film and has a bigger impact on the audience as I believe without music the
film would be just plain neutral. The impact it has on the audience is, it
allows the viewers to really feel the emotion on the screen, so without this
you wouldn’t have such a high emotional connection to the film.
The film uses
what are called talking head interviews with the players as it conveys their
side of the story. An example being when ‘Money’ is interviewed a number of
times after events happen to the team. By doing this, the filmmaker creates a
better and more reliable sense of the story and the events shown on the screen.
This then allows the audience to believe what they’re watching because ‘Money’
is a real person and a part of the story. This then offers the audience a
guarantee of integrity meaning we are watching the truth.
The use of
mobile, lightweight, handheld cameras creates a fly-on-the-wall feel as it
doesn’t influence or alter events being filmed. They may shoot up-close shots,
but they aren’t behind the camera directing the subject’s actions like they’re
actors. However, people who follow the cinema verité school of thought may
think that people knowing a camera is there may impact their action due to them
being on camera. But this also avoids accusations of interference or cinema verite.
Many key
features of the ending scene, the play-off game, are worth analysing. There are
a few camera-shots that stood out to me. At the end of the game there is a
tracking shot of the players which allows the audience to see each of their
emotions. There are many close up shots as they allow the viewers to be drawn
closer and involve themselves in what is happening. Also they observe the
emotions and reactions, such as sad, elation or tension. These shots are used
to privilege a certain person over others and position the audience with him or
her. An example of this is when they have a extreme close up of OC's face when
he is hugging his coach at the end to show that he is crying after their loss.
This then makes the audience feel sympathy for him as we only see him.
The music in
another key feature as the music matches the mood of the scene, so during the
final game we as an audience can guess whether they are losing or not just by
the music they use which sounds like an organ, which is usually associated with
funerals, and other religious ceremonies. So again it comes back to allowing
the audience to know how the players are feeling.
In the many
sections of the documentary the film makers use a lot of long takes with fewer
edits. If they used quick edits such as the ones in the action scenes and
montages, it wouldn't match what was happening in the scene. Long takes allow
viewers to immerse themselves fully in what is going on on screen, because life
doesn't have edits.
In the
mise-en-scene they rarely show more than a couple people, I think this is to
allow the viewers to emphasise with just a particular person instead of a
lot, because then it get confusing to the view who we are focusing on, I believe the filmmaker deliberately made sure less then 3 people were shown, especially people with the same feeling and emotion. Throughout I didn't really see a number of people in the same shot with different emotions, for example at the end where they lose, the camera focuses either on the players celebrating and then in the next shot the people upset, it's never in the same shot.
I feel
Undefeated does successfully engage the audience because it really makes you
want to find out how the cast end up and what happens to the players just by
showing their different stories. It also successfully get the message across,
because throughout we are kept up-to-date with the main players which then allows
their characteristics and personalities to be shown.
I really
enjoyed the documentary because it really plays with your emotions, one minute
you’re happy because they are winning, the next you anxious and sad because
‘Money’ gets injured and you’re worried about whether he’s going to play or
not. And then you’re excited and or on the edge of your seat while they’re
playing. So overall I feel like it is an amazing documentary because it also
shows you that no matter what happens, never give up. Also it shows the younger
audience to never feel you can’t do anything and that with a change of
attitude, you can achieve anything you want, and if you ever get knocked down,
like when they lost their final game, get back up and look at the positives and
try again.