Analysis
on Blackfish.
Blackfish
is an expository documentary as it speaks directly to the audience through
voiceover or titles, putting forward a strong argument and point of view. I
also believe it is also trying to persuade the audience to believe that the way
SeaWorld are treating their orcas (killer whales) is disgusting and outrageous.
Some
factors the documentary uses to do this is by using what is called archive
footage, videos from the past. One of the videos that stuck of to me was a
videotape of a SeaWorld trainer training one of the orcas but then the whale
becoming distressed which meant that he started to grab the trainer by the leg
and repeatedly pulling him right to the bottom of the pool. In my opinion,
while I was watching this, I didn’t feel as much sympathy towards the trainer
as much as some people think I should because throughout the clip it reminds us
that the orcas are so overworked, we heard that a whale called Tilikum had to
do a show every hour on the dot for eight hours, that it means they are seen to
become violent. Another clip that stood out to me was of the orca Tilikum
during a show with his trainer Dawn whom we learn was sadly killed during this
show by Tilikum. What struck me the most was how blasé the media was about this
death. In the documentary we see the media trying to put the blame onto Dawn
for having her hair in a ponytail which attracted Tilikum to then pull her into
the water. However there is video evidence that shows that it was her arm that
he went for. What made me angry the most was how SeaWorld as a company would
allow the blame to be on one of their own trainers. However the blame can’t be
put on the whale either because it was the way he was being treated that caused
him to become the way he did. I found this extremely disrespectful to not only
Dawn’s family but Dawn as well as she wasn’t there to defend herself or
Tilikum. I believe they did this because they only care about the fact that
they are a multi-million business.
Another
factor is the reconstruction/animation of the company in court as an
investigation went on about whether SeaWorld had been negligent. The head
trainer of SeaWorld was asked a question about whether Tilikum was capable of
pulling, to power phrase she replied “you’re a man capable of rape, therefore
could be a rapist”. I feel this comment
is so disrespectable to men.
In conclusion,
after watching the documentary I would now never go see a whale show as I would
feel extremely guilty getting entertainment through the whales suffering. However
other people have said that they still would go and watch as it is a once in a
lifetime opportunity.
No comments:
Post a Comment